The Living Wall stayed with me. Children could stand before it and find their own questions, drawings, and ideas. Their thinking had been noticed and returned to them. But reading about Moodle made me pause. It also makes learners visible. Would a learner recognize herself in what it records?
Romero, Ventura, and García (2008) describe how Moodle data can be mined to find patterns in students’ behaviour and performance. Course access, grades, assignments, and participation can help a teacher notice someone who may be struggling. I can see the value in this. A teacher might reach out while there is still time to help. Yet what does Moodle actually know about the learner whose footprints it captures? It may show that a student rarely logged in. Would it show that she was caring for children, working long hours, unwell, or learning somewhere else? A footprint shows that someone passed through a place. It does not tell us what she carried with her.
I also found myself asking an uncomfortable question about fairness. These are adult learners. If teachers keep reaching out to those who do not participate, what about the learners who quietly complete everything? I understand that concern. But I cannot assume that a student who appears disengaged does not care. Poverty, disability, language, caregiving, and access to technology can all affect participation. The same record might belong to two people whose lives are very different. I would want the data to give me a reason to speak with someone, rather than a reason to decide who she is before we have spoken.
This is where the question of human rights becomes quite concrete for me. Does the student know what is being collected? Can she see the conclusions drawn from it? What if she disagrees? A prediction can enter a teacher’s understanding of a learner before the learner has had a chance to explain herself. I find that troubling, particularly when collecting these traces becomes such an ordinary part of teaching that nobody thinks to question it. Something intended to support a student can become surveillance when she has little say in what is recorded or how it is used.
Jenson et al.’s (2016) study of Epidemic made me think about what else we might miss. Students’ decisions, paths through the game, and the comics and games they created offered different ways to understand their learning. There was room for creativity and irony, for doing something with knowledge rather than simply repeating it. How much brilliance remains hidden because we have already decided what evidence of learning should look like? Here, students could make something that researchers and educators could examine, but that also gave the students a way to look at their own understanding.
Wien (2013) describes pedagogical documentation through listening, creating traces of what we hear and notice, and returning to them to think together. Bjartveit et al.’s (2019) Living Wall helped me picture what this could mean for children. Their words, artwork, questions, and play could be revisited and taken further. To preserve a child’s thought and make space for others to consider it seems to say: what you think matters. Still, I wondered about what did not reach the wall. Someone chose the photograph or the sentence. Was there a child whose contribution was harder to recognize, or whose thinking did not fit what the adults were looking for? Even a mirror shows only what falls within its frame.
Visible Thinking Routines have been part of my teaching with students and my professional development work with teachers. I use them to invite learners to pause, question, and share their thinking. Reading about pedagogical documentation made me reconsider these familiar practices. When I invite learners to make their thinking visible, what am I able to notice, and what might I still miss?
A routine gives learners something to begin with and time to process their ideas. I value this because an immediate spoken answer is not the only way someone can contribute. Learners can put a thought into words, encounter another perspective, and find something further to consider. For me, knowledge develops through these encounters. A response gives us a place to begin a conversation, but I would hesitate to treat it as a complete account of what someone knows.
During professional learning for teachers, for example, I used Padlet to capture responses to Visible Thinking Routine prompts. Participants could read one another’s ideas, add their own, and elaborate in discussion. I later exported the responses to Excel and emailed them to the teachers so they could return to these shorter thoughts when working on Cambridge’s longer reflection prompts. The routine invited the thinking; keeping and returning the responses gave that thinking a life beyond the session. Reading about the Living Wall helped me recognize the importance of this return to the learner.
This also makes me think differently about assessment. The responses offered the teachers, their peers, and me as the facilitator something to consider together. They made aspects of understanding available for discussion rather than only presenting a final product for a grade. Returning to an earlier response could also give a learner a chance to ask: Do I still think this? What would I add now? A record of thinking might then help someone recognize a change in her understanding, rather than simply preserve her first answer.
Yet the routine itself deserves questioning. A prompt directs attention. It invites certain kinds of responses and may leave other questions unexplored. I choose the routine, so I am already helping shape what can become visible. If I look only for the thinking the prompt invites, what might I overlook? A learner may have noticed something important that does not fit easily into the response I have asked for.
I also need to ask of my own practice what I ask of Moodle. Confidence, language, writing fluency, and comfort with sharing can all influence a response. A short answer does not necessarily mean little thinking, and a fluent answer does not tell me everything about someone’s understanding. Learners need opportunities to explain, revisit, and question what has been recorded. When responses are preserved or shared, they should also know who will see them and have a say in how they are used. Making thinking visible carries a responsibility to keep listening after the response has appeared.
Across these readings, I began to see documentation as part of learning, rather than something that happens after it. What we choose to record shapes what we notice and what we come to expect from a learner. A Moodle profile may lead a teacher to expect difficulty. A child seeing her ideas on the wall may come to see herself as someone worth listening to. Neither record tells the whole story, but both can influence the story that follows.
These readings leave me wondering about the word “visible” itself. What am I learning about a student through her response, and what remains beyond the routine’s reach?
Bjartveit, C., Smey Carston, C., Baxtor, J., Hart, J., & Greenidge, C. (2019). The Living Wall: Implementing and interpreting pedagogical documentation in specialized ELCC settings. Journal of Childhood Studies, 44(2), 28–38. https://doi.org/10.18357/jcs441201919058
Jenson, J., de Castell, S., Thumlert, K., & Muehrer, R. (2016). Deep assessment: An exploratory study of game-based, multimodal learning in Epidemic. Digital Culture & Education, 8(1), 20–40.
Romero, C., Ventura, S., & García, C. (2008). Data mining in course management systems: Moodle case study and tutorial. Computers & Education, 51(1), 368–384. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compedu.2007.05.016
Wien, C. A. (2013). Making learning visible through pedagogical documentation. In Ontario Ministry of Education, Think, feel, act: Lessons from research about young children (pp. 27–30). Queen’s Printer for Ontario.